I once had a respected teacher in my graduate program make an offhand comment about starting one's career in beginning band then later on "moving up" to jr. high or high school. This broke my heart a little. For as much emphasis there is put on starting students with a strong foundation, there sometimes seems to be less respect for those who teach the little guys.
I did not let this comment or others I have heard get to me, because most days I absolutely love my job. Here's why:
1. Every single day I make many students appreciate music on a higher level.
2. I do teach those foundations, but I also help students fall in love with playing an instrument a little more each day. If I don't do my job well, those jr. high and high school programs would never have any students!
3. I get to TEACH. So much of the teaching older students (especially high school) is more directing rather than traditional teaching. Now before any feathers are ruffled, I know some phenomenal high school directors who do teach, but the job includes so much management and performance expectation that sometimes the in depth knowledge goals can be lost. I believe a strong elementary band teacher tends to slant more towards the comprehensive/general music philosophy when teaching.
4. I teach a subject students choose to participate in. Yes the glow can sometimes fade, especially for students who do not follow through with practice or effort. Overall though, students are so enthusiastic to come to my classroom.
5. I get to play everyday. I play with all my students, I play instruments all day long. How cool is that?
Of course in any teaching we have our challenges and frustrations, but overall in teaching beginners there is a least a little portion of pure joy every day.
Fellow band directors, what are some of your moments of joy?